After spending several days researching different Proprietary Trading Firm for funded trading accounts, our team at start-business-online.com team collected various data points. For this review, we will compare The5ers vs Topstep.
|Evaluation Metric||How they performed|
The 5%ers Challenge is by no means the most difficult. The fact that you are instantly funded and have a whole 180 days to complete the initial challenge makes the 5%ers one of the more straightforward options. That said, the price you pay is with a meaner margin of profit shares. You may get your foot in the door quicker, but there will be less on the other side as a result!
On the other hand The Topstep FX Challenge is a simple yet effective way of separating the wheat from the chaff. It is not a perfect system, and there are grievances about some aspects of it, but, overall, it is a transparent and fair means of ensuring you know what you are doing. It's a great platform to take on the challenge, and it has easy-to-understand metrics that reflect your trading progress.
The 5%ers make up the slack when it comes to the rules of using their platform. There are no restrictions on trading style, news trading, or the holding of weekend positons. For this reason, we give them a generous mark.
On the other hand The customer support with Topstep FX is good, clearly reflected across several review platforms. There are some complaints about the quality of customer support, but most of these have been responded to.
The the 5%ers Challenge fee is on the higher end of the spectrum at $275 per attempt. That said, you access immediate funds from the first use, which does compensate the sign-up fee for those successful traders.
On the other hand The cost on Topstep FX can be a positive or a negative depending on how quickly you pass the challenge. As it is a monthly payment, you will save money (compared to prop firms asking for more expensive one-off payments) if you complete the challenge quickly, but you will lose value for money if you are too slow.
the 5%ers scores poorly on this metric as their payout is significantly lower than competitors such as TopStep and FTMO. That said, however, where the platform disappoints in the 50% share they make up for with the exponential growth option: your account balance doubles with every milestone you reach.
On the other hand Compared to other proprietary firms, Topstep FX has a high percentage payout scheme or, to put it another way, it takes a lower percentage cut on your profits.
There’s no such thing as a perfect broker, but some are going to be a better fit for you than others.
Objectively, Topstep is more reliable based on our criteria above.
it takes a low percentage cut on your profits
5%ers Challenge fee is on the higher end of the spectrum
There are other holes in the 5%er offer
The 5%ers do a neat 50/50 profit split with successful traders. While this seems fair on paper, many of the rival prop firms offer much higher ratios. Therefore we’ve decided to view the payout scheme as the weakest point of an otherwise fairly good all-rounder.There are other holes in the 5%er offer too. The firm imposes restrictions on lot sizes [**this may no longer be true, have they removed the 0.65 lot limit?**] which doesn’t suit many trading styles.
Finally, if you're really not sure you can always use our free tool (takes 15 seconds) that will help you find a suitable Personalised Funded Trading Accounts based on your precise requirements here.